Maricopa County Sheriff debate: Paul Penzone and challenger Jerry Sheridan

In a debate hosted by Arizona PBS, The Arizona Republic, and KJZZ, Maricopa County Sheriff Paul Penzone and challenger Jerry Sheridan discussed the issues and explained their positions. The sheriff oversees more than 3,300 employees of the Maricopa County Sheriff’s Office (MCSO), the third-largest sheriff’s office in the nation.

Joining Ted Simons as moderators were Yvonne Wingett Sanchez of the Arizona Republic, and Steve Goldstein of KJZZ.

Topics for the debate included:

  • Melendres case
  • Racial profiling and mandated reforms
  • Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE)
  • Internal affairs investigation backlog
  • Joe Arpaio


Democratic incumbent Paul Penzone was elected in 2016 over former Sheriff Joe Arpaio. Penzone, a former Phoenix police officer, has worked in law enforcement and public safety for over 30 years and ran the Silent Witness program for seven years.

Republican challenger Jerry Sheridan worked in the sheriff’s office for 38 years and was Chief Deputy to the previous sheriff, Joe Arpaio. Sheridan, the son of an NYPD lieutenant, spent 20 years in an executive chief position before resigning in 2016.


Sheridan said he wanted Penzone to succeed and did not plan to run for sheriff after Sheriff Arpaio lost in 2016. “I didn’t have an idea that I wanted to run for sheriff, [but] when I started to get phone calls in the early part of 2017 from the people that worked at MCSO, the deputies, the detention officers and civilian employees… I noticed that was not going to happen,” said Sheridan in his opening statement.

“I do not want to run for another office. It’s about the people at MCSO and the public that they serve,” said Sheridan

Penzone introduced himself by addressing the rising tensions between civilians and law enforcement. “I ensure that everybody is held accountable, transparent and that they understand that leading by example, with integrity, is the number one attribute that is required in this office.”

Key Points

Judicial verdicts on the civil rights violations from the MCSO lead to mandated reforms on the department after the Melendres case. “There are over 200 paragraphs that the MCSO must be in compliance with for three consecutive years,” police documents stated.

Penzone said that complying with the reforms was a must, to regain the public trust lost with the “unforgivable” violations of the past. “The majority of men and woman of the organization are thoughtful, high integrity and very good at their job, but once you own a debt like this you are required to, in order to earn public trust back, to overcome it to be transparent and to strive and meet those orders.”

Clarifying his former role as Chief Deputy, Sheridan explains that he follows the guidelines set by the sheriff, but when elected, he will follow his own. “I am not Joe Arpaio, I am Jerry Sheridan.”

Currently, there is a backlog of over 1800 internal affair investigations, something Sheridan said did not exist during his time. Penzone argues that this was a result of Sheridan’s actions during the Melendres case.

Penzone and Sheridan both agreed on enforcing current ICE legislation with due process.


Sponsor message:

In this segment:

Paul Penzone, Maricopa County Sheriff
Jerry Sheridan, Candidate for Maricopa County Sheriff
Steve Goldstein, KJZZ Radio
Yvonne Wingett Sanchez, The Arizona Republic

Sponsor message:

Sign up to receive the Arizona PBS Insider

Get up-to-the-minute information about your favorite programs and learn more about Arizona PBS news and events.

POV: 'The Mole Agent'

"POV" presents the latest documentary from Chilean filmmaker Maite Alberdi, an unexpected meditation on aging and human connection in "The Mole Agent," airing Monday, Jan. 25 at 9 p.m. on Arizona PBS.

Arizona PBS serves up new digital series to support local restaurants

The COVID-19 pandemic has shaken the world’s restaurant industry, but chefs and restaurateurs throughout Arizona have pivoted to offer innovative takeout menus. Arizona PBS is highlighting those menus through a new digital-first mini-series starting Dec. 10.

Finding Your Roots digs into season seven

Finding Your Roots with Henry Louis Gates, Jr.

Today’s most compelling personalities discover the surprising stories buried within their own families in the seventh season of the critically acclaimed PBS series