New book brings back 2009 Sedona true-crime case

More from this show

In October 2009, self-help guru James Arthur Ray led a group of around 50 people up to Sedona for a wellness retreat where three people would die under extreme conditions. 17 years later, award-winning journalist Annette McGivney released “Plastic Shaman,” a book that explores the case in the context of a questionable wellness industry.

Author Annette McGivney joins “Arizona Horizon” to discuss her new release and the tragic details of the deadly case.

McGivney said she was inspired to write this book due to her journalistic background.

“As a journalist, I just wanted to look into how is it that this industry, the self-help industry, can allow someone that killed three of their clients to go back into business and attract more people,” McGivney said.

She said Ray told his followers that he was trained to lead a Native American sweat lodge. He packed 56 people into a hut covered with a tarp for eight rounds of heat therapy. Additionally, the followers were not provided food or water.

McGivney said 3 people died, and many others passed out from the heat.

McGivney said he was convicted two years later after lying to his followers about the deaths. She said they were trying to minimize the deaths during the event.

McGivney said, “They did a new-age channeling session after the people died and told other followers, who obviously it would make common sense to feel bad about people dying, but they told the followers, ‘Don’t feel bad; they wanted to leave their bodies because they were having so much fun’. And so they tried to really minimize the tragedy.”

She also said Ray’s false wellness retreat impacted Native Americans as well. She said they believed he had taken their spirituality from them and appropriated one of their rituals.

“I was very fortunate to get to know a group of Native Americans in Arizona that protested against James Arthur Ray. And attended every day of the trial and tried to raise awareness about the appropriation of their spirituality. And they continue to fight it. You know, it just keeps happening,” McGivney said.

Annette McGivney, Author, Plastic Shaman

SPOTLIGHT

Help for those affected by cuts to SNAP benefits

‘Crime and Punishment in America’ from Ken Burns

Donate your car or other vehicle to Arizona PBS

Join us for PBS Books Readers Club!

Subscribe to Arizona PBS Newsletters