Howard Center investigation reveals shootings across nation by little-known ICE investigations unit

Special agents with Homeland Security Investigations are found to be using high-risk tactics with little public accountability.

On Monday, Feb. 24, “Arizona Horizon” will air a documentary investigating federal police shootings by a little-known investigative unit of U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement. The report is produced by the Howard Center for Investigative Journalism, a national reporting initiative at Arizona State University’s Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication.

The report, “Homeland Secrets,” reveals officer-involved shootings nationwide and high-risk tactics by federal agents with Homeland Security Investigations, a division of ICE with broad policing authority in the United States and little public accountability.

A related news package is expected to run on “PBS NewsHour” in the coming weeks. The multimedia project, including original source documents, can be found at https://azpbs.org/homelandsecrets.

Eight Cronkite students spent five months reporting and producing the investigation, which includes an online multimedia presentation and a short-form video documentary. Starting today, the project is scheduled to be published by national and regional media including The Associated Press, The Arizona Republic and Cronkite News, the news division of Arizona PBS.

“Homeland Secrets” is the third investigation released by Cronkite’s Howard Center, a groundbreaking program designed to advance deeply researched watchdog journalism. The Center, along with the nation’s only master’s degree program devoted exclusively to investigative reporting, was established in 2019 with the support of the Scripps Howard Foundation.

Student journalists obtained and analyzed more than 1,500 pages of official reports and court records, which helped them detail and tally HSI agent-involved shootings around the country, in the absence of publicly available ICE data on federal shootings. They also interviewed eyewitnesses, victim family members, lawyers, national law enforcement experts, ballistics and toxicology experts, and consulted U.S. government audits to tell the story.

“This was a difficult assignment, but the Howard Center student-reporters rose to the challenge and exceeded our expectations and standards for high-level investigative reporting,” said Maud Beelman, executive editor and founding director of the Howard Center for Investigative Journalism at the Cronkite School. “There is nothing more important than transparency and accountability for those able to deprive others of life and liberty.”

Since 2011, there have been at least 13 shootings involving HSI agents – most in the last two years, according to the investigation. Reporters also found media reports on other HSI-involved shootings, but could not independently confirm the details and did not include them in the count. It’s not clear how many HSI shootings have occurred in the U.S. because ICE officials refused to answer questions and the agency’s data is not made publicly available.

The Howard Center confirmed that at least five people have been killed and 11 others, including a 4-year-old boy, have been injured in HSI agent shootings, which often occurred in parking lots outside strip malls or restaurants.

One suspect in California was shot in the back and killed, and an innocent man in the same state was mistakenly shot at after dropping off a child at school. Arizona had the most HSI agent-involved shootings, but at least eight other states had at least one since 2011, the year after ICE created HSI.

The investigation includes an 11-minute documentary that will air on Arizona PBS, reaching 80 percent of households in the state. The student-produced documentary was done under the guidance of the Howard Center’s executive producer, Lauren Mucciolo.

“This was a hard story to tell visually, but the student producers really showed off their creativity and technical prowess,” Mucciolo said. “I hope the documentary increases awareness and encourages greater public accountability.”

“It was shocking to find so many HSI-involved shootings across the country, and to learn that there was not much information available on them for the public,” said Mackenzie Shuman, a student reporter on the investigation. “I hope our story provides a stepping stone for others to study federal use of force.”

Arizona State University received $3 million from the Scripps Howard Foundation to establish the Howard Center for Investigative Journalism. The center offers multidisciplinary, graduate-level programs focused on training the next generation of reporters through hands-on investigative journalism projects.

The Howard Center at ASU and another at the University of Maryland honor the legacy of Roy W. Howard, former chairman of the Scripps-Howard newspaper chain and a pioneering news reporter.

In addition to “Homeland Secrets,” the Howard Center released an investigation last fall on pedestrian fatalities that was published in the Los Angeles Times and aired on PBS NewsHour. Another investigation, which ran in The Arizona Republic, explored low grazing fees on state land in Arizona and the related impact on funding for public education.

READ MORE:

Sponsor message:

Sponsor message:

Sign up to receive the Arizona PBS Insider

Get up-to-the-minute information about your favorite programs and learn more about Arizona PBS news and events.

'PBS KIDS Talk About: Race and Racism' special to debut on Oct. 9

The half-hour program will feature authentic conversations between real children and their parents, and will include content from PBS KIDS series Daniel Tiger's Neighborhood, Arthur and Xavier Riddle and the Secret Museum.

PBS NewsHour covers the 2020 presidential debates

As the nation prepares to vote in the 2020 presidential election, the PBS NewsHour team is providing coverage and analysis of the presidential and vice presidential debates. Watch each event live on Arizona PBS 8.1 at 6 p.m. or watch the livestream on this page.

'Art in the Twenty-First Century' introduces artists of today

Meet 12 artists and one artist collective behind some of the most significant artwork of the 21st century. These creators respond to the places they live and work, and show unabashed engagement with the world around them.