Constitutional expert discusses scope of Trump’s authority over Mueller

President Donald Trump is still under a microscope as Special Counsel Robert Mueller continues his investigation, and Constitutional Expect Robert McWhirter discusses the legality of he president firing Mueller.

“A special prosecutor like Robert Mueller can essentially only be fired for a cause – violation of policy, conflicts of interest, all kinds of things,” McWhirter says. “None of that can really be shown in this situation.”

This isn’t the first time we see a president come close to firing a special counsel who is heading an investigation that involves the president himself.  Forty five years ago, on October 20, 1973, President Richard Nixon tried firing Special Counsel Archibald Cox. Nixon went to the attorney general and deputy attorney general for help, both declined and resigned. The president eventually got to Solicitor General Robert Bork who agreed to fire Cox in return for a Supreme Court nomination. However, it was determined later that Nixon didn’t have the power to do that legally.

Can Trump fire Rob Rosenstein who does have the power to fire Mueller? McWhirter says yes. Is that a likely scenario? It’s hard to say, but it is a possibility.

“I’m sure Trump would like to do it, but there’s something really interesting that occurred here which is different than in 1973 with Archibald Cox,” McWhirter says. “Right after Trump pardoned Joe Arpaio, Robert Mueller did something really interesting. He made it a joint investigation with the attorney general of New York which means that even if Donald Trump fires Robert Mueller, this investigation goes forward.”

A federal prosecutor is bound by ethical constraints. Anything he presents to a grand jury is held in secret. However, if the attorney general of New York has the same information, there’s nothing that can be done by the president. If Mueller is out, New York is still in and the investigation can continue.

Sponsor message:

In this segment:

Robert McWhirter: Constitutional Expert

Sponsor message:

Sign up to receive the Arizona PBS Insider

Get up-to-the-minute information about your favorite programs and learn more about Arizona PBS news and events.

'We'll Meet Again' begins a second season of historic and memorable reunions

Executive Producer and Reporter Ann Curry. Photo courtesy of Stephanie Berger.

Join Ann Curry for a second season of "We'll Meet Again" as she reunites individuals who helped each other through turbulent times.

'Sinking Cities' shows how Earth's large coastal cities prepare for future survival

"Sinking Cities" is a four-part miniseries Wednesday nights that chronicles how New York, London, Tokyo and Miami are preparing for the real-time impact of rising seas and devising colossal new construction projects.

Enjoy season 2 of 'Jamestown' via Passport starting Nov. 21

Jamestown season 2

Download the PBS app to watch both seasons of "Jamestown on your own schedule via Arizona PBS Passport.